To celebrate the release of the new Phoenix album Ti Amo this June, below is a career retrospective. My thoughts on the albums and my top 10 Phoenix songs.
Thomas Mars has a distinctive vocal style, and Phoenix’s debut sees the band finding their feet. There’s a wide range of instruments and genre experimentation, although it all fits within a pop sound.
The opener “School’s Rules” has an enjoyable guitar intro which sadly isn’t a fully formed song. “Too Young” is a great single that has that fun-loving Phoenix-y sound and was included on Lost in Translation soundtrack. The blissful instrumental at the end of “Honeymoon” is beautiful. “If I Ever Feel Better” goes for fast spoken pop and is a bouncy, memorable track. “Embuscade” is a nice jazzy instrumental. “Summer Days” feels like a lesser variation of “Too Young”. “Funky Squaredance” at almost 10 minutes might be the most ambitious track, opening with 3 min of vocal distortion, then becomes funky and Daft Punk-esque, and at about the 6 min mark there’s a soaring guitar section. The closing track “Definitive Breaks” reprises Too Young, adding a saxophone.
Sporadically good, but a patchy follow-up to 2000’s United. The melodies are often uninspired and the word repetition on choruses to “Run Run Run” and “If It’s Not With You” are annoying. There aren’t really any big stand outs, with “(You Can’t Blame It On) Anybody” the most pleasing to the ears. “I’m an Actor” appears to be about addiction.
The track-by track order is lazy and hurts the listening experience. Why, for example, is “If It’s Not With You” featuring the repeated lyric “together”, followed by “Holdin’ on Together”, another song with “together” in the lyrics? Also, the instrumental “Congratulations” is too similar to the track that precedes it.
“Victim of the Crime” and the title track “Alphabetical” are more melancholy than anything on their debut, and seem to be about life as a pop star. Kudos for trying something different. “Alphabetical” works as a sad ballad, but the rest of the album plays it safe, presumably not wanting to alienate the fanbase.
It’s Never Been Like That (2006)
Rockier third album, the melodies are unmemorable. I initially liked the single “Long Distance Call” but after a few plays the word repetition in the chorus becomes irritating.
Favorite lyric from the track “One Time Too Many”: “Hard to tell you kindly that ain’t what I’m like”.
Too Young (Lost in Translation soundtrack)
If I Ever Feel Better
(You Can’t Blame It On) Anybody
One Time Too Many
Love Like a Sunset Part II (Somewhere soundtrack)